Also known as 17 West, this upscale bar didn't start serving women until the 1960s (which explains why there's only a men's restroom in the bar section). Good, reasonably priced beer selection (the lager was excellent) and samplers in off times. Call to check for lunch times, as we missed the lunch hour of 11:30-2:30 (though they say it's changing).
The Berghoff is known for their meats. I'd highly recommend the bratwurst.